If a person hasn’t experienced something directly (and they do not know anyone who has experienced the issue or challenge), they may not believe the problem exists or struggle to understand.
When it comes to challenges such as the crisis at the southern border, restrictions on voting rights and problematic policing, our culture has an empathy gap. While these issues register as major problems for people of color and people living in poverty, countless others are not always moved with compassion.
Social justice advocates often wonder how to bridge or tighten the empathy gap? One significant way is to strategically and ethically implore story in our outreach work. For information on how to tell impactful yet mindful stories, download this free infographic.
Why is this important?
If you are seeking to draw attention to a crisis, you must take people to the scene of the crisis. They must experience it visually, physically and mentally. Even if they are not physically present, they need to feel like they have experienced an issue directly.
I have heard preachers, rappers, country singers and others use stories masterfully. A personal favorite is Pastor Jeffrey A. Johnson Sr. of Eastern Star Church in Indianapolis. He ends most of his sermons with a colorful story. The prelude to his stories features an exasperated Pastor Johnson, who often says, “OK, OK. You all still aren’t getting it; let me tell you this way …” The story summarizes his message and uses a contemporary memorable story that the congregation can easily relate to and recall.
Telling Stories, Ethically
In some situations when advocates do use stories, they do so without the consent of impacted people. I recall being in a training with a social impact health organization. Faith leaders convened the meeting, and the speakers were extolling a public-private partnership that allowed them to provide health care services to a Massachusetts community. The speaker, no doubt in an attempt to document the program’s need, disclosed deeply personal information about one of the organization’s clients. The client was an older black woman who had made her share of mistakes. The speaker was a younger white woman, who appeared to have little in common with the woman who was old enough to be her mother.
The information disclosed made me cringe, not just because of its personal nature but because the protagonist in the story was not present. I kept wondering how I would feel if someone who was in my life to help me overcome obstacles shared the details of my life without me present. I asked the speaker if the woman in question had given her consent to share those details. She grew quiet and said she’d go back and double check.
To be clear, when I talk about sharing stories, I am proposing we do so ethically and with full consent. The Nonprofit Quarterly published an article in April 2019 on “poverty porn” and “survivor porn.” The author explains that survivors are often pushed to share traumatic experiences without regard to the emotional and personal consequences of doing so. This is not what I had in mind when I began writing this article. For communication strategy information on how to tell impactful yet mindful stories, download this free infographic.
When I advocate to use story, I mean to describe in colorful detail why an issue matters, whom it impacts and who the third-party validators are.
To be effective, a story must tell what is wrong and invite people in. In describing what has transpired, the story must provide an entry point for broader engagement. Seldom will we try things that we do not believe we can achieve. Therefore, in telling stories, we must convince people that all hope is not lost and that they can make a difference and that the problem is also theirs for the solving.
We know stories are important. They stimulate the senses, invite people in and give purpose to our action. Since we know this, let’s use them, but let’s do so while being mindful of consent and ethics.
Jennifer R. Farmer is the principal of Spotlight PR LLC. Check out our blog posts and subscribe for updates.

